There is something particularly appealing about single cask whisky. Rather than aiming for consistency from one batch to the next, each bottling captures one individual cask at a particular moment in its life. Once it is gone, it is gone.
One Cask at a Time is an Edinburgh-based independent bottler specialising in hand-selected single cask Scotch whisky. Its releases are bottled at natural cask strength, without chill filtration or added colouring, allowing the whisky and the cask it has spent its life in – to do the talking.

For this Tasting, organised by Steve Rush of The Whisky Wire, I had three bourbon-matured single malts to explore: a 15-year-old Glen Garioch, a 13-year-old Deanston and an 18-year-old Ledaig.
Three distilleries, three single bourbon casks and three quite different drams.
Glen Garioch 2011 – 15 Years Old
- Distillery: Glen Garioch
- Distilled: 20 January 2011
- Age: 15 years old
- Cask: Single bourbon cask #138
- ABV: 52.1%
- Outturn: 256 bottles
- Series: Chronograph
Glen Garioch is always a distillery I am interested to explore, particularly when presented without too much interference from the cask. This 15-year-old expression was matured in a single bourbon cask and bottled at a very inviting 52.1% ABV.
Nose: Sweet malted barley alongside stewed orchard fruits.
Palate: The texture is excellent – mouth-coating and substantial. The sweetness found on the nose arrives in abundance, backed by plenty of fruit and malt.
Finish: Long, with spiced oak, apple and cinnamon.
Overall: A very solid dram with an excellent texture and some beautiful flavours. The bourbon cask allows the Glen Garioch spirit to shine, while bringing plenty of sweetness and warming spice of its own.
Deanston 2013 – 13 Years Old
- Distillery: Deanston
- Distilled: 29 March 2013
- Age: 13 years old
- Cask: Single bourbon cask #1009
- ABV: 55.7%
The second whisky of the evening came from Deanston. At 55.7% ABV, this was the strongest of the three and it certainly made its presence known from the outset.
Nose: Initially alcohol-led, with a slightly acetone-like quality. Given some time, ripe grapes and oak tannins begin to emerge.
Palate: A wonderfully warming arrival. There are spicy oak tannins, but the whisky retains a lovely underlying sweetness.
Finish: Warm and drying, with a pleasing balance between the dryness of the oak and the warmth provided by the higher ABV.
Overall: Another excellent-quality single cask whisky. It feels like a cask that was allowed to mature until the bottler decided the whisky was ready, rather than simply being bottled when it reached a particular age.
The oak has a noticeable influence, but it never completely overpowers the sweetness of the spirit.
Ledaig 2008 – 18 Years Old
- Distillery: Tobermory
- Whisky: Ledaig
- Distilled: 7 February 2008
- Age: 18 years old
- Cask: Single bourbon cask #700122
- ABV: 54.3%
Last up was Ledaig, the heavily peated spirit produced at Tobermory Distillery on the Isle of Mull.
An 18-year-old Ledaig from a bourbon cask was always likely to be right up my street, and this did not disappoint.
Nose: Sea air, industrial smoke and crisp green apples. Frankly, it smells bloody gorgeous.
Palate: Mouth-coating oils and plenty of warmth. Vanilla fudge and honey are joined by cracked black pepper and a lovely coastal brine.
Finish: A powerful and delicious citrus note arrives first, gradually giving way to lingering saltiness.
Overall: An absolute belter. This is solid, unadulterated Ledaig from a bourbon cask – as it should be.
It combines oily texture, industrial smoke, sweetness, pepper and coastal character without any one element getting in the way of another. It has to be my pick of the three, although it was admittedly always going to have an advantage given how closely it matches my personal tastes.
Final Thoughts
This was a strong trio of single cask whiskies, and the order worked particularly well.
The Glen Garioch began proceedings with sweet malt, orchard fruit and an excellent texture. The Deanston followed with greater heat, tannic oak and a warming, drying finish. Finally, the Ledaig brought industrial smoke, citrus and coastal salinity to end the tasting in style.
Although the Ledaig was my clear favourite, there was quality across all three drams. More importantly, each whisky retained a clear sense of its distillery character. The bourbon casks supported the spirit rather than smothering it beneath layers of excessive wood influence.
That, for me, is exactly what good independent bottling should be about.
Many thanks to One Cask at a Time for providing the samples and to Steve Rush of The Whisky Wire for organising another excellent tasting and making these events possible.
Find out more at One Cask at a Time.
Samples were provided free of charge for the purpose of this tasting. As always, the opinions and tasting notes are entirely my own.

